Tuesday, September 08, 2026

A Welcome Change

Dr. Nechumi Yaffe (TOI)
I am truly excited about developments in the Charedi world, although I am not yet ready to celebrate.

According to the polls, the new Charedi party, HaTzibur HaCharedi, has not yet crossed the threshold needed to be included in the Knesset, which is about 150,000 votes. But at the last count, I believe they were at approximately 100,000. What this tells me is that there are a substantial number of Charedim who actually do feel an obligation to serve their country.

They also seem to agree that getting a decent secular education is a positive thing. Something that will help lift their community out of the poverty so many of them experience because of the lack of such an education. Which would better prepare them for the workplace. (An education available to women but not men.)

Religious Charedi schools that teach secular subjects already exist. But they are few and far between and are frowned upon by the mainstream. Those Charedim who send their children to schools like that are generally looked down upon, with some considering those schools’ religious teachings to be a watered-down version of the schools that offer only Torah studies.

It appears that things are changing, if the polls are right, I suspect that the numbers might even be higher once Charedi voters with those inclinations are in the privacy of the voting booth. A Charedi voter who may not want his vote in favor of the party to become public.

None of this is new. I’ve discussed it before. What is new, however, is the following, as reported by the Times of Israel:

For the first time in Israel’s history, an ultra-Orthodox political party on Monday selected a woman to run on its Knesset slate for the upcoming election.

The newly formed Charedi Public party, chaired by Moti Leitner, announced that Dr. Nechumi Yaffe, an ultra-Orthodox political psychology researcher, has joined the party, a day before the deadline for parties to submit their final candidate lists to the Central Elections Committee.

In a statement, the Charedi Public said Yaffe has worked with Harvard University on a research project focused on the ultra-Orthodox community and is a senior faculty member and researcher at Tel Aviv University.

What an amazing turnaround from the typical stuff you hear about the Charedi world in Israel. We now have a party that reflects a more diverse view of Charedi life and includes a large number of Charedim that believe in a more balanced way of life.

Much the same is true of the Charedi world in the U.S. There is a lot more diversity among Charedim here than there is in Israel. So even though the Charedi world here is moving in a rightward direction, it is not doing so as monolithically as does the Charedi world in Israel.

There seems to be a significant backlash among Charedim in Israel that may yet produce the grassroots changes that many of us are hoping for.

That being said, I’m sure that the mainstream Charedi leadership in Israel rejects this new party and probably doesn’t even consider it Charedi…

To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post - click on this link: substack. You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free.