![]() |
| Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jefferies |
I am reminded of this comment, frequently uttered by the
late Bob Collins, a Chicago radio talk-show host back in the 80s. It was his
humorous way of responding to generally bad news. The idea being that the bad
news wasn’t necessarily the worst possible news. But that it came pretty close.
I thought of that comment in light of what the Jewish world
is currently experiencing in a number of areas. Most of it is hardly
encouraging. And while these developments may seem unrelated, I think they are
connected in ways that should concern us.
These are some of my rambling thoughts about where we stand
today as Jews in America.
First, there is what appears to be a precipitous decline in
American support for Israel. This news is often accompanied by the caveat that
American support for the Jewish community itself has not really been affected.
I’m not so sure about that.
The reality may be that our standing among our American
peers has been negatively affected. That’s because most Americans understand
that Jews, as a community, generally support Israel. This makes us somewhat
guilty by association in the eyes of those who have come to view Israel
negatively.
And what has caused this change in attitude? Much of it has
to do with the way Israel’s war in Gaza has been portrayed. Palestinian
supporters and much of the media have presented Israel as indifferent to
civilian casualties, pointing to the tens of thousands of Palestinians
reportedly killed during the war.
It’s difficult to counter that narrative when the images of
death and destruction are broadcast night after night.
Even though the accusations are, in my view, profoundly
misleading, and even though there are facts that contradict the picture being
presented, it often doesn’t matter. One picture—or television image—is worth a
thousand words of denial and explanation. Legitimate though they may be.
The repeated use of the word genocide to describe
Israel’s actions certainly hasn’t helped. Israel’s denials and explanations
simply cannot compete with the constant barrage of those images accompanied by
accusations of deliberately targeting innocent Palestinians. That this is about
as far from the truth as one can get. There are substantial facts to support
Israel’s position. But that doesn’t change the impact of those images.
This is a major reason Israel has lost support. And since
American Jews are so closely identified with Israel, we cannot pretend that
this loss of support has no effect on us.
Then there is what can only be described as a political
earthquake: the Democrats’ remarkable victory at the polls, giving them the
kind of electoral success not seen in decades. That, too, does not bode
particularly well for those of us who care about Israel’s standing in
Washington…
To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post -
click on this link: substack.
You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free.









