![]() |
| IDF soldiers in mixed combat unit (TOI) |
Of course, no one disputes the obvious physical differences.
But hardcore feminists say the differences end there and insist that men and
women should be given equal treatment and opportunity in every other respect.
The goal of equality being paramount in their eyes.
I understand where feminists are coming from. I even agree
that in many cases women have been unfairly treated by societal norms. First,
men and women deserve equal dignity and respect. That’s a given. Any failure to
adhere to that principle is indeed sexist and ought to be eliminated from
public discourse. And certainly, there are jobs that both men and women are
equally capable of performing.
They ought to be given equal opportunities to pursue them.
The pay for the same work done by men and women ought to be equal as well.
There ought not to be a two-tier pay scale for the same job: one for men and
one for women. So, for example, a female accountant, doctor, lawyer, or teacher
should all be subject to the same pay scale as their male counterparts.
In these respects, feminist equality is indeed the right
call. But there are circumstances where equality is inappropriate, including
for religious reasons, even when women might technically be suited for the job.
This is especially true in the military, where feminism has gained ascendancy
to the point of overriding religious considerations.
As I recently noted, there is currently a serious area of
contention between feminist concerns about gender equality and religious
concerns. Religious men are being asked to serve alongside women, alone and
under secluded conditions, for extended periods of time. An example would be
service in an armored vehicle.
The argument in favor of the feminist position is that total
equality between the sexes overrides the needs of religious men, who must
adhere to those standards and should simply learn to better control any
possible physical attraction that might arise under those circumstances.
While it is indeed a religious imperative to control oneself
in compromising situations, it is also a religious imperative to avoid such
situations in the first place. Feminists reject this religious argument because
of their belief that equality trumps all else.
But just because a woman feels she is equal to men when it
comes to the demands of military service does not make it so. The reality is
that women are not equal to men in their physical capacity for that task. A
culture that promotes equality ignores that reality. And when a government
sensitive to feminist concerns endorses military service for women, they get
hurt.
I have always maintained that women are not as physically
capable as men when it comes to combat situations. The fact that they can pass
some arbitrary test designed so that women will pass doesn’t mean they are
equally capable with men. It simply means the standard has been lowered so that
women can pass at the same rate as men.
The counterargument is that standards don’t have to be that
high. If they did, the IDF would not have lowered them. That is, at best,
debatable, particularly in light of the pressure from feminists for equal
treatment. But even if you grant that the higher standards, which men can pass
more easily than women, aren’t necessary, doesn’t that itself demonstrate that
men and women are not actually equal in this respect?
It now seems there are further reasons why women should not
serve, and these have nothing to do with religion. In many cases, assigning
women to dangerous jobs that men can perform might actually cause them more
harm than they do to men…
To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post -
click on this link: substack.
You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free.









