Monday, October 26, 2026

Will Replacing Netanyahu Change Anything?

Gadi Eisenkot - Israel’s next prime minister?
I hate to disappoint all of Netanyahu’s critics who can’t wait for him to be defeated - and blame him for all the animosity toward Israel - but this attitude is sadly mistaken. Netanyahu has been an easy target for those looking to blame someone for all the criticism Israel receives. But, as I have said many times, Israel’s foreign policy and its approach to Judea and Samaria differ little among the candidates opposing Netanyahu. That is not what is being debated among Israeli voters.

The primary issue animating voters is “Charedim” and what to do about their refusal to serve in the IDF. Netanyahu is being blamed by secular and Religious Zionist voters for protecting Charedi interests - for delaying a vote on legislation that would require every Israeli citizen to serve in the IDF, with few exceptions. Legislation that would include severe sanctions for noncompliance.

Charedim, meanwhile, blame Netanyahu for failing to fulfill his promise to pass a law that would permanently exempt them from military service. This means that both sides will be voting for political parties opposed to Netanyahu.

Sorry to inform those who believe things will change under new leadership, but very little, if anything, will change. Israel’s foreign policy will very likely continue under any new leadership much as it has under Netanyahu. The rest of the world could not care less about the Charedi issue. Most of the world doesn’t even have a clue what a Charedi is.

Congressional animosity toward Israel will likely continue as before, if not get worse. All that hatred directed at Netanyahu will have been in vain.

Those who actually do care about the Charedi issue will be just as disappointed. Although Netanyahu’s opposition has come down forcefully in favor of using draconian measures to force compliance with the draft, I cannot imagine a scenario in which tens of thousands of yeshiva students fill prisons all across Israel. That is simply not going to happen, despite assurances from Netanyahu’s chief opponent, Gadi Eisenkot, that he will do so.

So whether Netanyahu wins or loses, nothing will change, at least not for the better. The world will still view Israel’s legitimate defensive war against the murderous enemies surrounding it as a form of genocide. And there will be little change in the number of Charedi recruits in the IDF.

The Israeli election is tomorrow. I expect voter turnout to be huge, but the electorate will be divided. Polls indicate that Eisenkot has a lead over Netanyahu in terms of the number of seats his party will win in the Knesset. But that does not mean Eisenkot will be able to form a government. He has already pledged not to include the Charedi parties. Although he has left open the door to a possible coalition with the Arab parties.

Finding coalition partners in a Knesset that will probably have more seats held by right-wing parties than by left-wing ones - might mean that Netanyahu will be able to forge a right-wing government despite having fewer seats. Netanyahu actually did that once in a previous election.

And the new coalition will surely be further to the right than the current one. One poll I saw says that Ben-Gvir’s far right party will actually increase the number of seats it wins in the Knesset…

To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post - click on this link: substack. You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free.

Disqus