 |
| This picture speaks for itself - Photo credit: Menahem Kahana/AFP/Getty Images |
I am truly saddened that this issue has blown up to such an extent. It appears that the fight between the Women of the Wall and their opponents has escalated.
It began as a few women who found the male modality of
wearing a Talis and Teffilin the most meaningful form of prayer for themselves. They showed up at the Kotel one day on a Rosh Chodesh. Rosh Chodesh is the first day of every month on the lunar calendar. That day requires special
prayers and a Torah reading. Their goal was to pray there once a month in their
own way – peculiar and upsetting though it may be to traditionalists.
That spawned protests… which spawned arrests of some of
these women who at the time technically violated the law (since overturned by
the court)… which spawned increased numbers of women joining WoW on their monthly prayer service there. That
spawned a call by rabbinic leaders for Charedi women – mostly from women’s
seminaries – to show up by the hundreds if not thousands, flood the Kotel Plaza, and pray there quietly.
Their overflowing numbers beat WoW to the punch there and left them no space to
pray. That event also brought out the worst in some of the male Charedi protestors
who acted like a bunch of wild animals - yelling, screaming, and throwing things at these
women. That spawned more determination than ever for WoW to achieve their goals
of equal rights to the Kotel. From the Forward:
Jewish Voices Together, founded and headed by Iris Richman, a Conservative rabbi and attorney, has organized rallies in support of Women of the Wall at various locations around the U.S. The organization comprises female rabbis of all denominations.
The title of its latest campaign is “100 blasts of the shofar/100 rabbinic voices for justice! Speak out for religious tolerance in Israel and Women of the Wall” – and its goal is to get 100 rabbis in the U.S. to devote their sermons over the upcoming Jewish holidays to women’s prayer rights in Israel. According to Richman, the effort has already surpassed that milestone, with 127 rabbis, as of this writing, agreeing to participate. Among the participants are 64 Conservative rabbis, 38 Reform and two Orthodox.
As I have said many times, I am not a fan of WoW. Although I know that many of
its members are sincere in their desire to pray in this unusual way; and simply want
to be left alone to do so, I cannot say the same thing for WoW’s leadership.
They have consistently been quoted as having the real goal of religious tolerance,
pluralism, and mostly feminism. WoW is simply a clever means so get this done. They
have found a way to technically not violate Halacha and thereby recruit the
left wing segments of Orthodoxy to support them. And as this new development
shows, they are gaining traction.
That feminism is at the core of this issue is not mere
speculation. For these leaders this is a feminist issue. The New Republic has a
lengthy article pointing to WoW as the “highest example of the renewed fighting feminist spirit in Israel”. They describe this as a new alliance between left wing
Orthodox feminist groups like Kolech and the Reform movement’s IRAC (Israel
Religious Action Center).
(I should add that such coalitions were bred by some of the
more disgusting attacks by extremist Charedim against non Charedim. Attacks that seem to be coming with more frequency these
days. Reading about the multiple attacks against Nili Philipp, a Dati Leumi religious
woman living in Bet Shemesh, made my blood boil. And this happened a year after 8 year
old Naama Margolese was attacked by the same kind of people! This is a far
bigger problem in my view that has yet to be properly addressed – but it is beyond the scope of this post.)
The more public opposition WoW gets from the right, the more
support it will gain from the left. Left Wing Orthodox organizations like Yeshivat
Chovevei Torah whose founder and leaders have rejected the ruling by Rav
Soloveitchik about joining heterodox movements on religious issues and now enthusiastically joins them - have added Orthodox legitimacy to WoW’s ranks. So a Rabbi on the far left
of Orthodoxy will feel very comfortable joining WoW in their quest for equal
rights at the Kotel.
While I understand their desire to open up Orthodoxy to all
segments of Jewry by pushing envelopes heretofore not sanctioned by any Orthodox
rabbinic leader, they are in effect aiding heterodox movements in their quest
for legitimacy. Which is precisely why joining heterodox movements on religious
matters was so strongly opposed by Modern Orthodoxy’s greatest and undisputed
leader, Rav Joseph B. Soloveitchik.
Although I agree with much of Rabbi Avi Shafran’s article on
the subject which appears in today’s Forward, I disagree with continuing to make an
issue of it. As I do with all the protests including the showing of masses of
traditional Jewish women showing up monthly at the Kotel specifically for the
purpose of denying WoW access.
It is true that these traditional women are all there
praying with sincerity and great devotion. But it is also true that many of the
Women of the Wall are doing the same thing in their own nontraditional way. I mostly
do not question their motives.
However, it is also true that the reason traditionalist women
are there is to counter WoW. There is no way they would be there en masse like
that on Rosh Chodesh if not called upon to do so in quiet protest by their
rabbinic leaders. Which of course brings out the usual gang of Charedi idiots
who like to cause trouble. And since the media will always focus on the trouble
makers, that is what the world sees most.
Rabbi Shafran complains that the media ignored all those
Charedi women who prayed peacefully at the Kotel. Which would show the world
that this is what the vast majority (…by a ratio of 100:1) Jewish women really want…
and that the real antagonists are the Women of the Wall, and not the Charedim.
It is true that little media attention is paid to huge number of women quietly praying in traditional ways at the Kotel. But it is not because the media is prejudiced against
Charedim. At least not in this case (…if ever really - but that is another
subject). It is because violence - no matter who is behind it - gets more attention than peaceful
prayer.
So in the end all of these protests and counter protests
fuel the controversy and gets more people involved. On both sides.
WoW is a celebrated cause all over Israel and now the United
States. People have been sensitized to feminist concerns. And this is now a high
profile example perceived as being anti feminist. Reform and Conservative
rabbis (and a few Orthodox ones) are joining the fight to allow these women to
pray as they choose. Even if it upsets the sensibilities of traditionalists who
comprise the vast majority of people that pray regularly at the Kotel.
In my view all this public opposition is to blame for perpetuating
the cause of WoW. It has exacerbated an issue that – had it been left alone –
would have no doubt died a quiet death. If not now then later.
As I have said many times - I do not believe for a moment that it will become fashionable
for women of any denomination to start wearing a Talis and Teffilin when they
pray. Whether it is at the Kotel or anywhere else. Had the Orthodox world
ignored them instead of organizing big prayer protests – peaceful though they
may have intended them to be (and which for the most part they were) - WoW
would have been ignored by the media and just about everyone else.
