Friday, April 25, 2025

The Passing of Sheldon Kirshner, a True Iconoclast

Sheldon Kirshner, ZL
Once again, as with my late bother, Barry, several years ago, I have been shocked by the sudden passing of a loved one on Pesach -  my Mechutan, the father of my son in law Neil (Rabbi Menachem) Kirshner.  

Having just returned from Israel - visiting my son and his family for Pesach, the last thing I did before returning to Chicago was attend his massively attended funeral there. I think I can say without fear of contradiction that the ‘standing room only’ crowd was one of the largest ever to attend a funeral in Israel of someone who lived in the US. And that was after the funeral he had the day before in Chicago. Which was surely as large if not larger! There is a reason for that.

Sheldon Kirshner was larger than life. That was the phrase I heard most by those who spoke a bit about him on that day. It was the first thing that came to mind after the initial shock of hearing of his death. He loved everybody. And everybody that knew him loved him back.

I don’t think he had an enemy in the world, even though he had a penchant for telling it like it is. When Sheldon spoke people believed him They trusted his sincerity even if they disagreed with him. Sheldon was an iconoclast. I envied his determination to be who he was without caring about what other people thought or did.

Sheldon was an ardent religious Zionist and yet he had tremendous repsct for the Satmar Rebbe. Refusing to criticize his anti-Israel views even though he strongly disagreed with him.

His knowledge of the Malbim had few peers. And Sheldon quoted him often when giving a D’var Torah. Which were often unique and original. Truly a brilliant mind that never acted in any way that flaunted it. A humble human being, to say the least. That alone would give him a ‘Lichtige Gan Edan’.

But his true essence was in how he raised his children. He was all about family. How he loved them.  And how they loved him back. When I say ‘family’ I mean those who considered themselves part of his family that were not at all related to him. People that came from difficult circumstances that he treated like his own 7 children. Often to the point of training them via his chosen profession as an electrical engineer, and helping them start a career. 

To this day they consider themselves to be members of the Kirshner family. He taught his children the true meaning of ‘Kol Yisroel Areivim Zeh BaZeh’. If he saw a fellow Jew in trouble, he did not hesitate to help them. That attitude rubbed off on all of his children.

And yet he never hid his emotions, crying at every family simcha. When reciting  a Bracha under the Chupah for one of his children or grandchildren he could barely make it through the Bracha without crying.

His Hashkafos were similar to mine. As was his approach to raising children, letting each child be who ever they chose to be (within the boundaries of Halacha, of course). As adults they have chosen the path that suits each one of them best from.  From modern Orthodox to Charedi. All are deeply devoted to Torah, its study, and Mitzvos.

They are different and yet they are as close as any family can ever be. Role models for the Jewish people.

There is so much more to Sheldon Kirshner I could say.  But the one thing I want to convey is how much I truly loved that man and how lucky I am to have become part of his loving family.

Baruch Dayan HaEmes