Friday, February 06, 2026

Extremism in Pursuit of God’s Will

‘Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice.’ This comment was made by Barry Goldwater in his acceptance speech for the 1964 Republican presidential nomination. In my view, this attitude has been responsible for some of the worst atrocities of our day. Atrocities committed against us (the Jewish people) from the outside, as well as atrocities of another sort committed from within, by our own people.

One does not have to think very hard about the atrocities committed against us by extremists on the outside. There have been too many to count, the latest of which began on October 7, 2023 - and lasted two years. And there remains the very real threat of further atrocities being committed against us by the extremist Islamic regime of Iran.

In all of these cases of extremism, it is not in pursuit of liberty, but in pursuit of something of a much higher order that is pursued: the belief that the atrocity being committed is in service of God. That it is God’s desire that His word (as understood by their beliefs) be established in the world, eliminating all other versions which are deemed false. When acting on behalf of God, ‘whatever it takes’ is what is required. Extremism becomes a given.

This same logic applies to our own religious extremists. Although I certainly do not compare them to Hamas or Iran in degree - we are not mass murderers - I do compare their motives: the use of extremism to advance goals they believe to be Godly.

There are basically two different sets of religious extremists. Both of which are devoutly religious, but could not be further apart in the goals they pursue. Yet they are disturbingly close in the methods they use to achieve them.

Extremist Charedim believe that their refusal to serve in the IDF is an ideal worth pursuing through extremist means, regardless of the damage it does or who gets hurt in the process. This is why they see no issue with violent protests that often cause bodily harm and, at times, even death. Sometimes to their own protesters. It doesn’t matter. To paraphrase Barry Goldwater: ‘Extremism in the pursuit of God’s will is no vice’.  To them it is instead a virtue.

Extremist Religious Zionists are no better...

To continue reading this post - and comment on it - click on this link: substack. To receive substack posts - you must subscribe. It's easy and it's free.

Disqus