Tuesday, November 03, 2026

Israel at a Crossroads

Eisenkot, Trump, and Netanyahu
There has been a lot of understandable hand-wringing over the last few days about events that will affect Israel’s future, which at this moment seems quite uncertain. One of those events hasn’t even reached fruition yet. The midterm election in the US is taking place at this very moment, and the results are far from clear. We have no way of knowing whether the new Congress will be more anti-Israel than the one we have had until now. Even though polls suggest that Democrats who have strongly criticized Israel are likely to win their elections, that is far from certain.

But that isn’t the only thing to worry about. There are several issues, one of which is the disappointing showing for the new Charedi party, Hatzibur HaChareidi. There were a lot of high hopes among many pundits who believed that they would receive enough votes to make a difference. Even if they didn’t get enough votes to secure seats in the Knesset; they would at least get enough to change their trajectory towards a more conciliatory approach to army service and educational reform. It was thought that the expected huge numbers of Charedi voters voting for Hatzibur HaChareidi would effect serious change in that direction. So that the large numbers of Charedim who felt this way could be accommodated.

That was more wishful thinking than reality. The poor showing of about 10,000 votes seemed to show that the Charedi populace doesn’t want change at all. That they are happy with the status quo of learning full-time, not getting any kind of secular education, and avoiding the army. That the hardships and sacrifices the rest of the country has endured—and is still enduring - don’t seem to faze them that much.

So change will not happen. Israeli Charedim have been indoctrinated into thinking along these lines. That they are not willing to serve is bad enough. But that they have become so callous to the suffering of others while exempting themselves from any possibility of such suffering seems to be how they wish to live. I see no hope for change or any kind of reconciliation between Charedim and the rest of the Jewish people in Israel. I see only greater distance being created between them.

Not at all happy about that. To say the least!

Then there is the election itself, which nobody won. And, it seems, nobody will be able to form a government. The enmity between the two camps is so great that a unity government is about as likely as El-Sayed converting to Judaism and becoming a supporter of Ben-Gvir. This will perpetuate the hatred between the right and the left.

I see no alternative to yet another election three months from now, which will likely return the same results. That may mean another election three months after that. On the other hand, the tens of thousands of expatriate Israelis who flew back to Israel to vote against Netanyahu are unlikely to do that again. And the huge Arab turnout that gave them 19 seats in the Knesset this time is unlikely to be repeated. So it is quite possible that a coalition could be formed by voters who will gravitate to one side or the other.

In the meantime, Netanyahu remains prime minister. Which, if you are a supporter, is a good thing…

To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post - click on this link: substack. You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free 

Disqus