 |
| Rabbi Avi Weiss |
It is ironic that Rabbi Avi Weiss is a regular Torah
columnist in this paper, for it is Rabbi Weiss who founded Open Orthodoxy back
in the nineties. Have they decided to
drop his column?
I don’t know how many times I’ve said this. But I guess I
have to say it again as there are increasing voices calling for yet another ‘split’
in Judaism. As much as I agree with the Jewish Press analysis of Open Orthodoxy,
it is wrong in my view to cast it into another movement that is outside the pale of Orthodoxy.
Yes, I agree that OO opens its doors too wide and can therefore
too easily slide the same slippery slope that the Conservative movement did - when
it too decided it needed to make itself more relevant to the melting pot spirit
of their times. That OO is doing the same thing with the feminist spirit of our
times is indeed a matter for concern. However they have not gone off the
reservation yet. And hopefully they never will. But even if they do at some
point down the road, it is way too premature to throw them out now.
Like I have said many times in the past,I do not believe
their feminist innovations will ever catch on with the mainstream. Even those
who support OO often tell me that it is not their cup of tea.
What about YCT? My hope is that they have gone about as far
left as they ever will and they will hopefully even pullback somewhat. In any case, I do not
see YCT as JTS in any way shape or form.
Yes, they have problems which I have criticized. But they do
believe in the events at Sinai and in following the letter of Jewish law. This
is something that JTS made a radcial departure from many years ago with their
acceptance of biblical criticism and their ‘Psak’ that one could drive to Shul
on Shabbos.
I do not foresee OO or YCT ever doing this. If or when they
do, then I will agree that they should be expelled. Until then, let us not be
any more divisive then we have to be.
