 |
| Louis C. K. |
Many of the accused are virtual icons of the
entertainment industry. Academy Award winners, even some that have been honored for their philanthropy
to humanitarian causes.
Of course the scandal is not limited to Hollywood.
Rabbis of all denominations and Hashkafos; Catholic Priests; Christian Ministers;
Presidents; politicians; and other high profile public officials have all taken advantage of their positions of power to
sexually harass (or worse) men, women, and children in their employ or otherwise in their control or even proximity.
But it seems like the epicenter of any and all sexual misconduct of any degree
is ‘Hollywood’.
I have discussed this issue recently and I hate repeating
myself. But the problem isn’t going away. The list of those accused of sexual
misconduct seems to be growing by leaps and bounds every day.
The conventional wisdom is that sexual misconduct
- from harassment to rape – is not a function of sexual desire. It is a
function of power and control. I believe that’s true. But there are a lot of ways
to assert power and control over other people that do not involve sex. So even though it is about power and control,
it’s about sex too. I don’t see how it’s possible to deny that. As a United States Senator put it (from the
senate podium at the height of President Clinton’s sex scandal) ‘If someone
tells you it’s not about the sex – It’s about the sex!’
How far back in history was sexual misconduct a
problem? Since the beginning of mankind’s reign on earth. The bible describes it
negatively as the behavior of the generation prior to the Mabul – the great
flood that destroyed all of humanity except for Noah and his family. The bible is filled with examples of sexual
misconduct.
Are we more civilized today than we were then? As
a society have men learned to be better behaved around women? I had always thought
so. But I’m not so sure anymore. Yes, I believe most of us are better behaved.
But it seems we haven’t really moved the needle too much from the pre Mabul
days of Noah.
I don’t know what percentage of the male population
is guilty of the kinds of things all of these prominent men have been accused
of. But I’m sure it’s a lot more than anyone has ever imagined. What happened
to our society’s civilized behavior? I guess in all too many cases it’s a facade. While not all men are ‘pigs’ sadly there are
a lot of us that are.
I wish I could say that religious people are immune
to such behavior. But obviously they are not. The Catholic Church has one of
the guiltiest records of child sexual abuse of any religious institution. And
the list of Orthodox rabbis guilty of such conduct has grown and seems to continue
to grow to shocking proportion!
I am now convinced that even with all the victims
coming forward now, it is only the tip of the iceberg. There are probably still
plenty of people that want to keep the abuse they suffered secret for fear of
embarrassment – for themselves and their families.
The question I keep asking myself is, ‘Why?’ Why is
all this happening? Why are there so many victims coming forward now? Who will
be exposed next? And of no small concern is the possibility that in the current climate
of justifiable public outrage over sex abuse will be taken advantage of. An
unscrupulous individual can accuse an innocent person of it and will surely be believed.
We are now at a point where every accusation is considered to be true.
Even
though almost all accusations are true, in the current climate it would be far
too easy for an innocent person’s life to be ruined by an unsubstantiated and
false accusation of it, added to all the accusations that are true. How can we
prevent that? And more importantly, what can we do to change the culture?
Stronger laws and better enforcement is one
answer. Encouraging survivors of abuse to come forward and testify against their
abusers is another. Treating survivors of abuse more respectfully is yet another As is teaching people to better protect themselves against it. But there is more we can do as a preventative measure. Which
brings me back to Hollywood.
As I have said in the past, I cannot help but believe
that Hollywood’s immorality in sexual matters is related to it being the epicenter
of sexual harassment (and worse) right now. It is a culture that objectifies women.
And thus people with no self control and sociopathic tendencies will use women as
objects of sexual gratification.
The hierarchy of the entertainment industry (Hollywood)
gave powerful former icons like Harvey Weinstein an easy road to satisfy his
lust. The culture of celebrity does that too. So that a Bill Cosby, Kevin
Spacey, or Dustin Hoffman can hit on any target they choose. As can powerful media types like Roger Ailes and Bill O'Reilly. Usually the victims are targets of
opportunity. The objectification of women (or in the case of a gay man like Spacey
– the objectification of other men or boys) is in large measure the business of
Hollywood. And we are now reaping its fruit.
Any power player who wishes to satisfy his lust will
have a sense of invincibility about himself. At least according to those who
have been caught with their proverbial ‘pants down’. When in positions of high
power no matter what part of society in which that power lies, they seem to think
they can do what they want because they will never get caught. Whether it was Kennedy
(both John and Edward), Clinton, Bush (41), Edwards, McGreevy, Spitzer, Hart, Petraeus, Katzav… the list goes on. Nowhere is
this more common than in the entertainment industry. As the current President
noted several years ago while expressing his own objectification of women – and
what he could do to them as a powerful celebrity.
I’m not sure we are going to be able to change the
culture of objectifying women in this country – or any country. Or objectifying
anyone against their will for purposes of their own sexual gratification. But
I sometimes wonder if the lengths gone to by the
extremes of Orthodoxy don’t actually have some merit. Not that I am recommending
it. Nor is it even true that these communities immune from it. They clearly
are. But I have to believe that the concept of having modesty standards is an
important building block against at least the frequency with which these things
happen.
I do not recommend women start wearing burkas. Or
that religious areas should have men and women walking on different sides of
the street, or separate seating in buses or even at weddings. But I do think there
is a benefit to modesty standards in the following sense. The less men and
women are involved with each other the less opportunity there is for
misconduct. What constitutes normal versus extreme? Determining that is beyond
my pay grade. But it should be based in Halacha and related to the individual culture
in which anyone finds themselves
This will not stop harassment or abuse. That will
unfortunately continue. As long there are sociopaths that are willing to use other
people for their own self gratification, they will find a way. But clearly, there is something to be
said for minimizing interactions between the sexes. Because if nothing else, it
will reduce opportunity for sexual harassment and abuse . And that will reduce
the incidence of it.
