Sunday, April 19, 2026

A Conservative Rabbinical Student Speaks Up

American Jewish University president Jay Sanderson
Conservative Judaism is dead or dying. And The state of American Jewry is dire, with only a generation to fix it.

I don’t like beating a dead horse. But whenever a serious publication like Commentary revisits this issue, it’s hard to stay silent.

The above sentiments were not expressed by me, but they certainly could have been. They are two of the three sentiments expressed by American Jewish University president Jay Sanderson. AJU is the parent organization of the Ziegler School of Rabbinic Studies - one of only two schools that ordain Conservative rabbis.

None of this is new. The Conservative movement has been in decline for quite some time. Nor is it news that its leadership recognizes it. What is different about this particular article by S.A. Weiss is his personal reaction to it. Weiss identifies as a third-year rabbinical student at Ziegler pursuing semicha - ordination as a Conservative rabbi two years from now.

What is not surprising is what Conservative leadership is trying to do to fix the problem. Which is almost certain to put the Makah B’Potish – the ‘final blow’ on its demise. Their plan is…

to shift away from traditional rabbinical-school subjects such as Mishnah and Talmud toward more “timely” and “relevant” topics like conflict resolution, AI, and social media.

This is not a course correction. It is an acceleration of the very trend that brought the movement to this point. For decades, Conservative leadership has treated classical Torah study as increasingly irrelevant, replacing it with contemporary concerns. Now, even the pretense of Torah as the central organizing force appears to be fading. The idea that Torah should inform all of their decisions and practices will effectively be excised from their program.

Please do not misunderstand…

To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post  - click on this link: substack. You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free.  

  

Disqus