Rahm Emanuel's Anti Israel Speech

Rahm Emanuel addressing an audience at Tel Aviv University

Rahm Emanuel delivered a speech at Tel Aviv University yesterday that was both surprising and disappointing. To say the least. It did however receive extensive mainstream media coverage because it reinforced the narrative many media outlets already promote about Israel and its prime minister. But I shouldn’t have been surprised.

Emanuel has made no secret of his apparent ambition to seek the Democratic presidential nomination in 2028. Unlikely though that is to happen, to have any chance of winning that nomination, he must align himself with a Democratic Party whose increasingly influential progressive wing views Israel as an international pariah led by ‘war criminal’ Benjamin Netanyahu, whom they portray as beholden to extremist coalition partners and settler violence.

Much of the anger, disgust, and venom directed at Israel by the far left is expressed through the demonization of Netanyahu. They treat the war in Gaza as “Netanyahu’s war,” making him personally responsible for every civilian casualty. Their narrative assumes that had any other Israeli leader been in power, the war would have been conducted differently and the civilian death toll dramatically reduced.

That claim ignores reality. Israel’s political opposition overwhelmingly supported the war’s objectives and the IDF’s military tactics and strategy. They understood that Hamas had embedded its military infrastructure within civilian neighborhoods, schools, hospitals, and mosques precisely because civilian casualties would become propaganda victories. Israel repeatedly warned civilians to evacuate targeted areas, saving countless lives. Tragically, many civilians still died, but much of the world ignores Hamas’s deliberate strategy of maximizing those deaths for political gain. Not to mention exaggerating the number of civilian casualties

Israel’s opposition also understood that after October 7^th, eliminating Hamas’s military capability was essential to preventing future massacres. Yet critics reduce the conflict to the simplistic claim that Netanyahu intentionally targeted innocent civilians.

For many liberals, however, Netanyahu himself has become the issue. They see him as arrogant, divisive, and willing to publicly challenge American presidents, particularly Barack Obama over the Iran nuclear agreement. Their hostility toward him has increasingly become hostility toward Israel itself.

Emanuel attempts to strike a middle ground. He condemns Hamas and acknowledges the atrocities of October 7 while simultaneously arguing that Israel has become a pariah because of Netanyahu’s leadership. The implication is clear: remove Netanyahu and Israel will once again regain the respect of Democrats and much of Europe.

That premise is deeply flawed. I am tired of hearing demands that Israel apologize for defending itself. I am tired of hearing that a two-state solution is the only path to peace, despite decades of history suggesting otherwise. I am weary of antisemitism masquerading as anti-Zionism and of claims that Netanyahu somehow manipulated President Trump into confronting Iran.

What disappoints me most is seeing someone like Rahm Emanuel, once regarded as a strong supporter of Israel, now describe it as a pariah state because of its elected leader…

To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post  - click on this link: substack. You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free.