Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Orthodox Judaism and the Gay Jew

Should We Welcome Gay Jews into Our Community?

Jewish Action magazine tribute to Rabbi Moshe Hauer (Forward)
The question asked in the subtitle might instinctively elicit a reactionary and unequivocal “No.” And yet, “No” might not be the right answer. In my view, it depends on what that acceptance includes. And that is key.

To briefly summarize the Torah law on this subject: It is considered a serious violation of Halacha for a man to engage in a sexual relationship with another man. The Torah calls it a to’eivah, commonly translated as an abomination.

So that knee-jerk reaction might be the one most people feel is correct. But the Torah does not speak to one’s physical attractions, only to specific behavior. A physical attraction that is not acted upon in this way is not, in and of itself, forbidden. That, of course, makes eminent sense. People can’t help whom they are attracted to. They can only control what they do about it.

As a matter of public policy, Judaism therefore opposes gay marriage, since that legitimizes not only the desire but also a lifestyle conducive to acting upon it. By the same token, however, one must never mistake one’s identity as gay for a forbidden physical act that might be part of a gay couple’s life. We are not commanded to make assumptions about how people live, regardless of how they identify, gay or straight. This should not mean that we deliberately overlook something considered a serious violation of Halacha. It only suggests that we be Dan L’Kaf Zechus and not assume the worst.

So how do we split hairs here? Can an Orthodox community accept a gay couple who wishes to be part of that community? A couple that is observant in every respect? Or should they be ostracized?

It clearly isn’t easy being gay in the world of Orthodoxy. The stigma associated with the possibility of engaging in behavior that the Torah considers abominable makes such acceptance difficult for most people. On the other hand, we also know that the struggles of gay people to survive in a straight world are so great that depression and suicide are not uncommon. They want to be accepted for who they are and contribute to the community, just like everyone else.

And yet, as a practical matter, I find it difficult to believe that a gay couple would generally be accepted into an Orthodox enclave. Hiding who they are is not usually an option. So they end up feeling alienated from the very community in which an Orthodox gay person grew up and of which they still want to be a part.

This is a conundrum that has yet to find a solution. The idea of “hate the sin, love the sinner” is a difficult ask for most people. And yet I think it may be imperative that we accept it. Because the consequences of not doing so may rise to the level of Pikuach Nefesh.

Accept it, that is, as long as we don’t accept the behavior that usually accompanies gay couples. The devil is in the details, of course. How we tread that fine line is beyond my paygrade. How do gay people achieve social acceptance when everyone suspects that their private lives probably includes a sexual relationship? I don’t have the answer to that.

Interestingly, one of the most honored Orthodox rabbis in recent memory, Rabbi Moshe Hauer, whom we lost too soon last year at age 60, seemed to be tackling this problem before he died. He didn’t just theorize; he lived his values…

To continue reading - and/or to comment on this post - click on this link: substack. You must subscribe to receive new posts. It's easy and it's free.   

 

Disqus