 |
| Muslim Brotherhood member Ayman Al Zawahiri |
Those daily images of the bloody carnage will generate the same attitude
in most people. It is difficult to see dead bodies lined up in makeshift morgues,
severely wounded bloody victims, and wives and mothers who cry out in pain at
the loss of a husband or child.
It is easy to sympathize with them. The reportage is
extremely sympathetic to the underdog victims. But as is always the case with
media reports - rarely do they see context. It’s always about the underdog. In
this case the underdog is the Muslim Brotherhood.
Let us take a moment and look at some historical and
religious context.
Egypt’s former dictator, President Hosni Mubarak, was ousted from office after a popular uprising by Egyptian citizens . Democracy was their cry. They had apparently had enough of Mubarak. But he fought back. People were killed. Mubarak was eventually overthrown by his own
military and arrested. After a brief military rule elections were held and
Musilm Brotherhood candidate Muhamed Morsi was (somewhat surprisingly to me) elected
by a majority of Egyptian voters.
Morsi pushed through a new constitution that was largely based on
Islamic law. In the meantime Egypt’s economy collapsed and is in shambles. People
started protesting again. The Egyptian military once again stepped in and quickly removed Morsi
from office.
Hundreds of thousands of Muslim Brotherhood members were
outraged seeing themselves robbed of their freely elected leader. They started
protesting in huge numbers. The army fought back with live ammunition. The
result is what we are now witnessing in the daily news coverage.
The US has wisely not reduced it financial support of Egypt. But it has not been shy
about criticizing the Egyptian military’s lethal tactics in trying to suppress Brotherhood protests.
How are we to see what is going on there? How does what is
going on in Egypt affect us, the Jewish people? Whose side should we be on… if
any?
I think the first thing we have to do is look at what the
Egyptian army is really fighting. They are fighting a movement that is extremely
anti Semitic as a part of its religious
theology. They believe that Israel is a gang, not a country and they will fight
it until they destroy it.
The Muslim Brotherhood honors Osama Bin Ladin and
condemned his assassination by the United States. Ayman Al Zawahiri the current head of Al Qaida is a member of
the Muslim Brotherhood.
The Muslim Brotherhood denies the Holocaust while praising Islamic Jihad and martyrdom. They condemn the
peace treaty with Israel and they consistently call for the destruction of
Israel. In addition, their Arabic website alleges that Jews have created evil
in the world throughout history.
It is therefore my view that it does not serve Israel or
US interests to support the Muslim
Brotherhood – even though the Egyptian military tactic is brutal.
No one supports man’s
inhumanity to man which is what it seems like the Egyptian military is doing. But as Chazal tell us - when one is kind to the cruel, they will
end up being cruel to the kind. To peace loving democracies like the United
States and Israel and to most other Western countries, the Brotherhood should be seen in
the same light as Hamas, Hezbollah, and any other Islamist Jihadist group. They
should be seen as determined to prevail at all cost. Including at the cost of innocent
lives as anyone who lost a loved one on 9/11 can tell you.
What about the Egyptian military? They reflect the will of
secular Egypt and have their support. But there is no love lost between Egypt’s
secular population and Israel. As Muslims - they are in theory just as opposed
to the Jewish State as the Muslim Brotherhood. But they are not in favor of
hostilities with the Jewish State and are probably more willing to stand by the
peace treaty with Israel as a means of achieving stability in the region.
Secular Egyptians are more interested in improving their lives materially and having
a government that responds to their needs. Israel’s legitimacy is in their minds a back burner issue for now.
What about the current carnage of Brotherhood members? I’m
sorry. I don’t have too much sympathy for religious fanatics whose ultimate
goal is to destroy the Jewish State and kill Jews… a movement that has spawned the likes Ayman
Zawahiri.
They look like innocent victims
in the eye of the camera. They portray themselves as devout Muslims whose only
goal is to restore their Islamist leader and live religious lives. And they seem
to be systematically slaughtered for simply expressing their protest in large
numbers. But that is far from the complete picture - to say the least.
In my view the United States should take a ‘hands off’ approach.
Let the Egyptian people fight it out. Let nature take its course. The Egyptian
military should not be hampered. Financial aid should not be withheld since it
helps ensure the continuance of the peace treaty. The Muslim Brotherhood must be
defeated. If we allow them to succeed, we allow religious extremism to succeed and increase. And that is the last thing the world needs right now.
I wonder how many secular Egyptians miss Mubarak right about
now? He may have been corrupt. But Egypt was a lot better off when he was
around. And the Middle East was a lot more stable. The democracy that was hoped
for by the west after he was deposed - never happened. Democracy is not only
about having a free election. It is about including free and democratic principles
that do not force religious law upon all its citizens. That’s what happened
with Morsi. And that is why I’m glad he’s gone.
A word about fighting terrorism as perpetrated by the above-mentioned movements .The world should once and for all realize that what they
are really fighting is not terrorism but an ideology. I don’t think they do. This
is not about supporting a poor underdog… or a brutal military bent on
destroying innocent people. This is a holy war initiated by a militant and
fanatic religion that loves death more than we love life. How do you fight an idea? I don't know. But the more the world realizes this fact, the better prepared they will be to deal with it.
